A Good Old Fashioned Orgy (2011)

Alex Gregory and Peter Huyck teamed up to write and direct the risqué romp A Good Old Fashioned Orgy (2011), not to be confused with the Queen song “Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy” (1976). This R rated flick follows a group of friends who need to say goodbye to their fading youth. Overgrown man-child Eric Keppler (Jason Sudeikis) is pushing 30, yet still spends all of his time getting wasted with his shirtless buddies Mick McCrudden (Tyler Labine), Adam Richman (Nick Kroll), Doug Duquez (Martin Starr), and Glenn (Will Forte). But Eric gets a rude awakening when his wealthy father (Don Johnson) puts the Hamptons vacation house (which also serves as Eric’s party palace) up for sale. Faced with the terrifying prospect of finally having to grow up, these party dawgs decide to go out with a bang — literally. In other words, they’re going to throw an orgy! The movie includes David Koechner, Lake Bell, Leslie Bibb, Lucy Punch, and the abs on Rhys Coiro! Even though hilarious, this box office flop is actually more touching than raunchy (touching as in “awww,” not “awww yeah.”) But fans of man shouldn’t be too disappointed since the pic’s orgy scene features a full-frontal shot of Fred (Jon Stafford). Plus, Mr. Sudeikis and Mr. Kroll engage in a great gay smooch. Better yet, they and Tyler bare their bums. If that’s not arousing enough, Mr. Starr shows off his raw rump and fake cock in the gag reel. We’d gladly gag on that prosthetic peen!