Tarnished Notes (2016)

Tarnished Notes is based on the real-life, real Baptist, real love triangle fiasco of Dan and Donna Arnold and their lover Carl Stuffel. They've all been renamed here (Jim and Judith Daniel with a lover named Kyle), but the story is almost the same. Baptist Minister of Music (I had no idea that was a thing) Jim has secretly been bisexual all his life and hooks up with his twenty-something barber and ex con Kyle (Ryan Joyner) in a motel, eventually having him move into his family's house under the guise of helping him escape from drugs. What Jim didn't know is that Judith would start having sex with Kyle two, and that the pair might be plotting to have him murdered. Yikes! It's easy to see why they both love him, though - sexy Kyle goes shirtless for his hookups and while he does yardwork!