Blackmail Boys (2010)

A part-time student/gigolo named Sam (Nathan Adloff) and his gay lover Aaron (Taylor Reed) form a plan to record and extort money from one of Sam's clients, an outwardly homophobic yet inwardly-closeted married evangelical preacher and author, so they can finally afford a nice wedding and honeymoon. Things go horribly wrong, as they usually do, but not before Nathan, Taylor, and their mark (played by future indie director Joe Swanberg) show us everything they got - dicks, balls, and hairy booties - in a myriad of up close and personal sex scenes. This graphic nudity mixed with the shaky handheld cam, understated acting, and theme of young love is peak mumblecore (low budget and naturalistic)  cinema. There’s no doubt these blackmailing boys will make your own balls blue!