One Night at McCool's (2001)

One Night at McCool's (2001) stars Liv Tyler as a seductive young woman who three different men fall for over the course of one disastrous night. Matt Dillon is one of those men, the bartender at the bar she goes to. They hook up and he goes shirtless for a beautiful night at McCool's. Paul Reiser plays her lawyer and is convinced to defend her when they have a sexy bondage time. She ties him up shirtless, so we see his chest hair. We're innocent of having dirty thoughts until proven guilty - and after seeing his bulge in his leather underwear, we're guilty as discharged.